Why is my phobia getting worse?

They said you would grow out of it. Here is why your phobia might be getting worse instead.

Maybe it’s needles, a pap smear, or the dentist’s chair. Whatever your fear is, you may have been told you’d get over it.  Yet years later, it hasn’t faded. If anything, it feels harder to overcome. This isn’t a sign that something is wrong with you, or that you lack bravery. It’s a sign that your fear has been caught in a very common loop. Once you understand how that loop works, you can start to step out of it.

Fear makes a prediction

At its core, fear is a forecaster. Its job is to protect us by predicting danger: “If you do this, something terrible will happen, and you won’t be able to cope.” Sometimes, fear gets it right, or partially right. A lot of the time, it’s just guessing, and guessing the absolute worst-case scenario. It also guesses that you won’t be able to handle whatever happens. It tells us that we’ll fall apart, freak out, or be irreparably harmed. No wonder it’s so scary even thinking of making an appointment!

Then we avoid, avoid, avoid

When we avoid something, our brain doesn’t get the chance to learn new things about it. For example, fear may warn us that a trip to the dentist will be so overwhelming that we won’t be able to handle it. Then we put it off. Our dental issues may get worse, increasing our anxiety and sense of certainty that a dental appointment will bring suffering that we simply can’t handle. The more we put it off, the less data our brain has to challenge fear’s hypothesis.

Relief sets the trap

The relief we feel after avoiding something is real, and that is exactly what makes the cycle so sticky. This is called negative reinforcement: a behaviour becomes more likely because it reduced something unwanted. Every time avoidance brings relief, your brain files it away as the strategy that “worked.” Avoidance becomes the one, and only, strategy our brain can think of.

Fear spreads

Left alone, a phobia often doesn’t stay in its lane. Fear can start to attach to things that share features with the original trigger. A fear of the dentist might expand to any medical appointment, the smell of a clinic, or even talking on the phone to book a visit. Over time, the list of things to steer around can quietly grow. The long-term cost is a smaller, more scary, more restricted life.

So… Just Do It?

Don’t worry, the point of this entire article isn’t to bully you into “just doing it.” But, there are things you can do that start to reverse the cycle and get you un-stuck.

If avoidance keeps fear going, the way out is to give your brain the new information it has been missing. But that doesn’t mean you have to suffer through a terrifying experience, get “flooded”, or grit your teeth and bear it.

Avoidance can be subtle. Many of us develop what are called safety behaviours: small habits that feel like they help us get through a feared situation. An example would be checking and checking for reassurance, avoiding talking or thinking about it, or having a “lucky chapstick” without which we feel like something bad will happen. These things feel helpful in the moment, but they can leave the brain believing, “I only survived because I did that one specific thing.” The fear stays intact, and its predictions go unchallenged.

Breaking the cycle

You can gradually and deliberately approach what you fear, in a planned and supported way, so your brain can see what actually happens.

Current research suggests exposure doesn’t work by erasing the fear. Instead, it helps the brain build a new, competing memory: “I expected disaster, and something else happened, instead. Interesting!” The goal isn’t necessarily to feel calm the whole time – for some of us, that is an impossible ask! The goal is to get curious and see if the brain can learn from a new set of experiences, even while you feel anxious.

Here is what that can look like:

  • Start with identifying a manageable step. Not too scary, but not too easy either. For the dentist, that might be looking at the clinic’s website.

  • Name fear’s prediction. What exactly does fear tell you will happen, and how bad would it be? Make this concrete: write it down or speak it out loud.

  • Then take a look at the website, as planned. See if you can do it without any of your usual safety behaviours: so, no seeking reassurance, no distracting yourself so you’re not actually paying attention, and no tapping your lucky rock. This means you can give yourself credit for making it through, and no credit to a safety behaviour.

  • Notice what really happened. Afterward, ask yourself: what did I expect, compared to what actually happened? Get concrete about this as well: perhaps you felt anxious for a few minutes, then it felt manageable, then it spiked a bit, etc.

Practise in different settings. New learning sticks better when it isn’t tied to a single place or situation. Also, do something small daily. You might get more gains from consistency than trying a whole bunch of exposure on one day.

You can get some ideas on how to do mini-exposures here.

You don’t have to do this alone

Facing a fear you’ve avoided for years can feel daunting. Exposure is not about throwing yourself into the deep end or proving anything. It works best when it’s paced, collaborative, and built around what matters to you. A therapist can help you understand your own cycle, plan steps that feel doable, and make sense of what you learn along the way.

You may not simply grow out of a phobia, and that’s ok. With a few brave steps, you, you can grow through it.

Clay Roth

Clay Roth is a Registered Clinical Counsellor with a passion for treating medical phobias and trauma. Their background is in trauma therapy, EMDR, OCD treatment, ACT, and IFS.

https://braveenough.ca
Next
Next

Supporting A Loved One With Severe Medical Anxiety